The final, 18th installment of Guess the Mess was won by Robert but Jack and Alexa were there too. Tell us your thoughts on Instagram at Killer.Reactions (Fay Dewitt, Lead Belly, and Paul Kelly)
Jazmin recounts the strange story of Colin Ireland with killer reactions from Robert, Alexa, Jose, and Jack.
Jack recounts the chess board story of Alexander Pichushkin with killer reactions from Jazmin and Gabi.
The 17th installment of Guess the Mess ended in a four way win but we all knew it. The combined knowledge of Jack, Robert, Alexa, and Jose prevailed yet again. Tell us your thoughts on Instagram at Killer.Reactions (Aaron Hernandez, Rae Carruth, and O.J. Simpson)
Jazmin recounts the advent-ageous story of Billy Gohl with killer reactions from Jack, Robert, Jose, and Alexa.
Jazmin recounts the little pee-pee story of Billy Glaze with killer reactions from Jack, Robert, and Alexa.
Jazmin recounts the side story story of Edward Edwards with killer reactions from Robert, Jose, Alexa, and Jack.
Jazmin recounts the sacrilegious story of Bible John and/or Peter Tobin with killer reactions from Jose, Alexa, Robert, and Jack.
The 16th installment of Guess the Mess had only ONE winner, and it was NOT my cousins (or Jose). Tell us your thoughts on Instagram at Killer.Reactions (Skylar Deleon, Ryan Grantham, and Salman Khan)
The 15th installment of Guess the Mess had only two winners, and it was Jack and Alexa. Robert & Jose were left in the dust. Tell us your thoughts on Instagram at Killer.Reactions (Phil Spector, Christian Brando, and J.R. Smith)
Jazmin reads different accounts of interactions with serial killers with killer reactions from Jack.
Jazmin recounts the unholy story of Hans B. Schmidt with killer reactions from Alexa, Jose, and Jack.
Jazmin recounts the butterbox babies story of Lila and William Young with killer reactions from the OG Broke Squad: Jack, Robert, and Alexa.
The 14th installment of Guess the Mess had only one winner, and it was Alexa. Robert & Jose were left in the dust. Tell us your thoughts on Instagram at Killer.Reactions (James Stewart, John Huston, and Craig MacTavish)
Jazmin recounts the insane story of the British Airways Flight 5390 with killer reactions from JOSE, Alexa, Robert, and Jack.
Jazmin recounts the boogeyman story of Mr. Cruel with killer reactions from Alexa, Jose, and Jack.
Jazmin recounts the Hello Kitty Murder with killer reactions from Jack, Robert, Alexa, and Jose.
Jazmin recounts the 19 century stories of Hadj Mohammed Mesfewi & Ali Asghar Borujerdi with killer reactions from Alexa, Jose, and Jack.
Jack and Robert won, while Alexa and Jose failed.. I was honestly expecting everyone to win! The 13th installment of Guess the Mess ended in a tie. Tell us your thoughts on Instagram at Killer.Reactions (Henry Riggs, Alec Baldwin, and John Landis)
Jazmin recounts the unsettling story of Debra Jeter with killer reactions from Alexa, Jose, Jack, and Kody.
Jazmin recounts the vicious story of Angela Simpson with killer reactions from Jack, Alexa, Robert, and Jose.
Jazmin recounts the “social worker” story of Irina Gaidamachuk with killer reactions from Alexa, Jose, Robert, and Jack.
Jazmin recounts the fiery story of Leonardo Morita with killer reactions from Jack.